Science Fail: The Crazy Way to Deal With Crazy

Gericault, “Portrait of an Insane Woman”

In the early nineteenth century, information about mental illness was limited to say the least.  There was even a surprising “study” done at the intersection of art and science.

Psychiatrist Etienne-Jean Georget, among other scientists at the time, believed that mental illnesses such as kleptomania and dementia could be diagnosed by recognizing certain facial features in a patient.  He asked Theadore Gericault of Raft of the Medusa fame to paint a series of portraits of subjects deemed insane.  The result was ten paintings depicting conditions such as obsessive envy, general insanity, and “delusions of military rank.”

Of course mental illness cannot be diagnosed simply by looking at a person.  Fortunately we know much more now.  The portraits were not successful in their original purpose, but they were groundbreaking for another reason.  This series was one of the only examples at the time of mental illness being portrayed with dignity.  The touching works can still resonate with us today.  Although they don’t work as diagnostic material, they shed light on the human side of mental illness.

This entry was posted in European Art, Science and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Science Fail: The Crazy Way to Deal With Crazy

  1. Pingback: Crazy Cats and Sane White Space | The Starving Art Historian

  2. Amanda Walczesky Danielson says:

    I remember telling Andrew, when we were talking about these particular works, that someday if I were to follow one of my dream art jobs and found even ONE of the lost portraits I would dedicate my discovery to him. He thought this was humorous and said “good luck with that”.

  3. Andrew Graciano says:

    You know what’s really crazy? You posted this on my birthday–October 23. Hi Amanda! The lost paintings are probably in someone’s attic or in an old, long forgotten storage room at the Salpetriere mental asylum. Vlad the Impaler, however, probably still roams the earth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s